Backyard and Beyond

Starting out from Brooklyn, an amateur naturalist explores our world.

As John Burroughs said, “The place to observe nature is where you are.”

Confusing Fall Warbler


Roger Tory Peterson, the Bronx’s great contribution to ornithology, has a couple of famous-in-the-field pages in his field guide called “Confusing Fall Warblers, etc.” On their way south, the warblers have left their breeding plumage behind them, so they are not nearly as dramatic as in the spring. Juvenile birds, born this spring and summer, and females, will usually may have different plumage patterns than the adult males. Hence, it can be a challenge to ID one of these fast-moving small birds if you’re not a hard-core bird dog.

Recently in Brooklyn Bridge Park, I found one for you. Big clues are that incomplete eye-ring, dark eye-line, and pale eyebrow. Also, the yellow under the tail. It becomes a process of elimination. This is a Palm Warbler, Dendroica palmarum.

Um, I think…

3 responses to “Confusing Fall Warbler”

  1. Whatever it is, I’m impressed you got such a great photo of it. Warblers seldom pose for pictures, so this is a wonderful shot.

    1. Thanks. It was fairly close at eye-level, so that helped.

  2. No clue about identity, but look at that puffy belly down!

Leave a reply to mthew Cancel reply